Choosing between vinyl plank flooring (LVP) and engineered hardwood can be challenging – that’s why you’re here, right?
The thing is, both flooring options offer distinct advantages depending on your lifestyle, budget, and the specific needs of your home.
TLDR; Which Flooring Option is Right for You?
Choose LVP if:
- You need water-resistant, low-maintenance flooring.
- You prefer easy DIY installation.
- You are working with a limited budget.
Choose Engineered Hardwood if:
- You value the authentic look and feel of real wood.
- You are comfortable with ongoing maintenance.
- You want to invest in a long-term flooring solution.
In the remainder of this article, we’ll compare these two flooring materials across several critical factors to help you make an informed decision.
We’ve also included real-world commentary from Reddit users who have shared their experiences which may help to give some additional perspective.
What Are Vinyl Planks and Engineered Hardwood?
Luxury Vinyl Planks (LVP)
LVP is a synthetic flooring designed to replicate the appearance of natural materials like wood or stone. It’s composed of multiple layers, with a wear layer on top to protect against scratches and dents.
Known for its water resistance and low maintenance, LVP is popular for areas like kitchens, bathrooms, and high-traffic rooms. It also comes in a variety of textures, colours, and finishes to match different design preferences.
“A good quality vinyl plank is superior… Engineered hardwood is susceptible to water damage while high-quality vinyl plank isn’t.” — Reddit user [Canadasparky]
Some users caution that not all LVP products are equal in quality. Cheaper options may feel flimsy, which can impact comfort.
“The floor feels like plastic, and it has a subtle flex, which hardwood doesn’t have.” — Reddit user [dave_cap]
Engineered Hardwood
Engineered hardwood is constructed with a thin top layer of real wood glued to multiple layers of plywood or fibreboard.
This structure gives it more stability than traditional hardwood, making it suitable for environments with fluctuating humidity.
Engineered wood offers natural wood’s beauty and is more resistant to warping than solid wood.
“We had engineered hardwood in our last house, and while it was beautiful flooring” — Reddit user [Ok_Lingonberry_2013]
However, as with any wood product, excessive water exposure or the claws/nails of pets can still cause damage.
“My friend’s Pergo flooring soaked up water like a sponge after a dishwasher leak… the floor crumbled, and she had to replace it.” — Reddit user [Zealous_Tie]
Key Factors for Comparison
Installation Process
The ease of installation can significantly impact your flooring choice if you are doing it yourself.
Obviously, the installation difficulty won’t matter if you are planning to hire a professional flooring installer to implement your choice of floor.
LVP: It’s designed for simple installation, with click-lock systems or self-adhesive planks. Many homeowners find it manageable without professional help.
“Go for a rigid vinyl plank with good padding… Installation was easy, and it feels great underfoot.” — Reddit user [Dont_Touch]
Engineered Hardwood: This flooring type often requires professional installation, especially for glue-down or nail-down methods.
However, newer click-lock systems make DIY installation possible in some cases.
“Refinishing is required every few years, especially where there’s heavy use.” — Reddit user [ToojMajal]
Look and Feel
Both flooring types offer appealing aesthetics, but the choice depends on your priorities.
LVP: LVP can mimic wood and stone textures, offering a stylish yet practical alternative.
“Go for a rigid vinyl plank with good padding. It feels like hardwood, and installation was easy.” — Reddit user [Dont_Touch]
Some users warn that lower-quality LVP may feel less comfortable underfoot, detracting from its visual appeal.
“I replaced engineered hardwood with LVP… The wear resistance is miles ahead, but I do miss the solid feel of wood.”
— Reddit user [Vlad_Homeowner]
Engineered Hardwood: With a real wood veneer, engineered hardwood provides an authentic look and feel that many homeowners prefer. It adds warmth and character to any room.
“Hardwood can’t be beaten… lasts a lifetime and is easy to clean, even with pets.” — Reddit user [Corazon_54]
Durability and Longevity
Durability is often a deciding factor, especially in homes with children or pets.
LVP: It’s highly resistant to water, scratches, and dents, making it ideal for high-traffic areas.
The waterproof nature of LVP ensures it holds up well in kitchens and bathrooms.
“I replaced engineered hardwood with LVP four years ago, and it’s held up great with kids, dogs, and visitors. The wear resistance is miles ahead.” — Reddit user [Vlad_Homeowner]
Engineered Hardwood: Although it offers good durability, it’s more prone to scratches and dents over time.
However, it can be sanded and refinished to greatly extend the lifespan ofthe wood.
“Our last house had engineered hardwood, but it didn’t hold up to our dogs, even with trimmed nails.” — Reddit user [Ok_Berry2013]
If you have active pets or small children, LVP may be the more practical choice.
Moisture Tolerance
Water resistance is a critical factor for flooring, especially in moisture-prone areas.
LVP: Completely waterproof, LVP is a top choice for kitchens, bathrooms, and basements.
“The waterproof aspect has been a lifesaver with kids and pets.” — Reddit user [Vlad_Homeowner]
Engineered Hardwood: While it’s more moisture-resistant than solid hardwood, prolonged exposure to water can still cause damage.
“Engineered wood performs well with light water exposure, but not in high-moisture areas like bathrooms.” — Reddit user [Zealous_Tie]
Maintenance and Cleaning
Maintenance is another key consideration when choosing between these two flooring types.
LVP: Low-maintenance and easy to clean with regular sweeping and damp mopping.
“I love my vinyl flooring because I don’t worry about spills or scratches.” — Reddit user [Wonderwall]
Engineered Hardwood: While beautiful, it requires more upkeep including refinishing in your high foot traffic areas.
“Refinishing for hardwood is necessary over time, especially in busy areas.” — Reddit user [ToojMajal]
Cost Comparison
Cost plays a major role in decision-making for most homeowners.
LVP: Generally more affordable with lower installation costs, but there are differing levels of quality at different price points.
“Don’t cheap out—spend $3-4 per square foot for better quality LVP.”
— Reddit user [Canadasparky]
Engineered Hardwood: While more expensive initially, it can add long-term value to your home.
Eco-Friendliness
Both LVP and engineered hardwood offer eco-friendly options.
Look for recyclable LVP products or engineered wood certified by PEFC or FSC to ensure sustainable sourcing.
Which is Better? It Depends on You!
Both vinyl plank flooring and engineered hardwood have their strengths, making them suitable for different situations.
LVP offers practical advantages like water resistance, durability, and ease of installation, making it ideal for high-traffic areas.
“The water resistance is definitely a huge selling point!” — Reddit user [Altruistic_Highway]
Engineered hardwood provides natural beauty, warmth, and the option to refinish, making it a timeless addition to many homes.
The best flooring for your home will depend on your lifestyle, budget, and design preferences.
If you need further guidance, consulting with a flooring professional can help you find the perfect fit.
View the full Reddit thread here.
